CATAWBA ISLAND TOWNSHIP
OCTOBER 28, 2026 ZONING COMMISSION MINUTES
Attendee
William Baker
Members of the Commission in attendance were Chairperson Jordan Davenport, Kevin Howe, Paul Shaw along with alternates Douglas Sprouse and James Atkinson. Matt Gottran and Greg Hart were absent. Also in attendance were Trustee Chris Cellier and Jean Hartline, Commission Secretary and Zoning Inspector.
Chairperson Davenport called the meeting of the Catawba Island Township Zoning Commission to order at 7:00 p.m. For the record, he identified the date as October 28, 2026.
The room was asked to stand for the pledge of allegiance.
The meeting then moved to the agenda provided by Chairman Davenport.
Agenda Item 1 – New Business
No new applications at this time.
Agenda Item 2 – Approve the Prior Meeting Minutes
September 23, 2026 meeting minutes were approved without any changes.
Agenda Item 3 – Address Unfinished Business From Prior Meeting
Last month Mr. Bill Baker brought to the floor a couple items for review in the form of a resolution. Chairman Davenport asked Mr. Baker to review his requests with two major courses of action. Mr. Baker identified major concerns being: the first being that accessory building should not be larger than the primary dwelling. The second is that garage door size should be restricted as these large overhead doors are unsightly. This goes back to the recent West Catawba Road accessory structure that is significantly larger than the home and “skirted” the zoning code by providing a breezeway connecting the accessory structure to the existing home. The breezeway has no doors to the dwelling unit and that the breezeway “goes no where” but to the (solid) side of the house. This condition also exists on Porter Road. Ms. Hartline offered that much of Porter Road is Agricultural Zoning (which have different accessory building criteria). Mr. Baker also noted that there are also the same large outbuilding at Island Pines and Peachton and the new house at the Moorings also has a large overhead door. He indicated that there is commercial boat storage available for citizens need. He continued that a standard garage door is eight (8) foot door. Mr. Baker indicated a standard is needed for large out buildings (accessory structures/garages).
The Chairman asked how this breezeway changes an exterior building as part of the house. Ms. Hartline indicated that this is an interpretation of our code and that our code says an attached garage then falls under the rules of the home including increasing the height of the attached garage to 35 feet, which would otherwise be 15 feet if the garage is detached. The code does not describe what “attached” means. Ms. Hartline also indicated setbacks change on attached garage versus unattached with attached follow the home setbacks. Ms. Hartline noted that detached garages must be subordinate to the dwelling and require only five (5) foot setbacks. Attached garages do not have size restrictions in our code.
Chairman Davenport indicated he does not see size limitations on attached garage size and the garage would be part of the house (35’ height included but would need to follow setbacks of the house).
Also, many of the HOAs have their own limits on garage door heights. Chairman Davenport indicated some HOAs do not allow outside storage of boats in the yards and the ability to store a boat in a garage (with a larger garage door). Mr. Baker indicated that the BZA takes HOA input/regulation seriously. Mr. Baker indicated that we do not have an architectural board to control door heights and, thus, we need code for such.
Chairman Davenport discussed the complications (by Ohio Revised Code) for such an architectural board that was determined in previous years not feasible (for Catawba Island Township) due to the requirements included a need for an architect on the board.
The question is: can we restrict door height as an architectural items? Ms. Hartline offered that the better define the language on attached and detached garages. A detached garage would have to be under 15 feet and thus a limiting factor on garage door height and a limit of garage size to 750 – 950 SF (depending on residential zoning district). For attached garage the height could go up to 35 feet and there would need to be some code language that the control the door height.
The code was reviewed on accessory structure (detached garages). Chairman Davenport indicated that with detached garages there are limitation. If attached the garage can follow the home code on height and size is not really restricted.
Mr. Baker discussed window escape routes in which Chairman Davenport said that is Ottawa County code not Catawba township.
Chairman Davenport indicated that the Township has a consultant under contract that are experts in the area of Township zoning code that we will be bringing these topics to for their assessment. Mr. Baker indicated that the company is very reputable. Ms. Hartline will work with Trustee Cellier and the new consultant on these topics.
Mr. Baker indicated that this should be for new construction and existing conditions would not be impacted.
Chairman Davenport recommended that we table this until we get an answer to the questions
Agenda Item 4 – New Business to Introduce to the Commission
The 2027 calendars based on all being the 4th Wednesday of the month. The November 17, 2026 and December 23 days tend to create conflicts. It was decided that the meetings will both be moved up one week to November 17 and December 17 (with an asterisk that indicates these day)
The 7 PM meeting time was reviewed for a potential change to 6 PM. It was decided by the Zoning Commission to leave the at 7 PM for 2027.
A clarification on the code dock restrictions which are in zoning districts but not in the PUD section. At this time, this will remain but may need a future amendment. Dockage for the NE PUD was discussed that subletting/renting of docs is not desired.
Trustee Cellier offered that the Nor Easter PUD will be in front of the Board of Trustees on Thursday November 5, 2026 as a special meeting (outside of the normal Trustee meeting schedule).
Adjournment
The next scheduled meeting is November 18, 2026 and is adjusted from November 25th due to the conflict with Thanksgiving. With the completion of the agenda, a motion to adjourn the meeting was made and seconded. The vote was unanimous to adjourn the meeting at 7:45 PM.
Respectfully Submitted,
Jean Hartline, Secretary/Zoning Inspector