PHONE: 419-797-4131

CATAWBA ISLAND TOWNSHIP

CATAWBA ISLAND TOWNSHIP

CATAWBA ISLAND TOWNSHIP

Board of Zoning Appeals October 14, 2026

MINUTES OF THE CATAWBA ISLAND BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS

October 14, 2026

Attendees
Bill Nottke
Kathy Nottke
Alison Perlaky
William Halm
Paul Perlaky
Lee Short
Jeffrey Simerl
Frank Stams (Did not sign in but spoke at meeting)

Chairman Brian Caldwell called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. The Pledge of Allegiance was recited. Board members in attendance included: Chairman Brian Caldwell, Mike Schenk, Rebecca Dubber and alternates Flint Heidlebaugh and Rich Smetzer. Bill Baker and Doug Blackburn were absent with Mr. Heidlebaugh and Mr. Smetzer sitting in for Mr. Baker and Mr. Blackburn. Jean Hartline, Zoning Inspector/Secretary was also in attendance.

Chairman Caldwell read through the meeting process.

Old Business
None

Case #233086 William and Laurie Halm 5844 E. Twin Beach Road

Applicants propose an attached patio involving the extension of the existing house roof lines. The addition size is 27 ft x 20 feet (540 SF). The applicants are requesting an area variance for left yard setback of 3 feet, a right yard setback of 8 feet and rear yard setback of 5 feet. The property is located at 5844 East Twin Beach Road and is known as Lot 4 of Gem Beach 4. The Property is Zoned C-4/R-4. It was clarified that the current plan is an attached cover porched and no longer a detached pergola.

Additional Information: This is a revised plan from both the May 13, 2026 BZA and July 9, 2026 meetings. The former cases are summarized as follows:

Case #233035 May 13, 2026: A detached pergola (25 ft x 15 ft) was proposed. This pergola had variances on both side yards (left was 3 feet and right was 10 feet). Rear yard setback was 5 feet which met code for an accessory (detached) structure.

Case #233086 July 9, 2026: A detached pergola (23 ft x 15 ft) was again proposed but with the left yard setback changed to 5’ to meet code. Pergola length was reduced by 2 feet (25 ft to 23 ft) to provide for the 5 ft left side yard. The right side yard setback still required a variance for 10 feet (existing house side yard setback is 8 feet). This plan was tabled at the applicant’s request as he desired to move toward an attached covered patio.

Mr. Heidlebaugh had a conflict of interest and was recused from this case.

Mr. William Halm is representing the case and was sworn in. Chairman Caldwell noted a partial wall in plan for a storage area and a knee wall behind the grill and the previous foot print approval was based on no walls (open patio). Mr. Halm said there is not a knee wall on the grill side as their grill is portable (not built in) but had desired a knee wall on one side for screening for adjacent neighbor. Mr. Halm indicated that there are no knee walls presented on the drawings. Ms. Dubber asked about the wall of the existing house in the picture. Picture was unclear in the corner of the proposed structure. Mr. Halm indicating that the portion Ms. Dubber is the existing house wall to which the covered patio is attached to.

Chairman Caldwell asked if there were any comments from the audience. There were none and the meeting was closed to the floor.

A motion was made for an executive session. Ms. Hartline conducted a roll call for executive session which started at 7:11 PM. The executive session ended and the public meeting continued after roll call at 7:24 PM.

The finding of facts was reviewed with the following results.
Finding Of Facts: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Owner’s Responses: Yes No No No Yes No Yes
Board’s Responses: Yes/Agree 4 4 2 1 4 4 0
No/Disagree 0 0 2 3 0 0 4

The Chair closed the meeting and requested a motion approve, modify or deny the case. Mr. Schenk made a motion to approve the case with the setback variance (Left Side 3’, Right Side 8’ and Rear Yard 5’) and was seconded by Ms. Dubber. The case was denied with a vote of No by 4.

Mr. Halm asked why he was denied. However, Chairman Caldwell indicated that he could petition an appeal to the County Common Pleas court and/or get with the Zoning Inspector.

New Business

Case #233127: Jeffry Simerl 5582 Helmsman Drive
Applicants propose an attached addition for a garage and bonus room. The applicants are requesting an area variance for front yard setback of 25 ft (code is 35 ft. This was corrected at this meeting as the agenda indicated 5 ft). The property is located at 5582 Helmsman Road and is known as Lot 157 of Johnsons Landing. The Property is Zoned R-3.

Additional Information:
Front Yard averaging would allow for a 28 foot front yard (Section 7.01d). There were no variances recorded for this property. Per the Auditors site, the house was constructed in 1960. A porch was enclosed in February 1988 and a deck was added in June 1988. A shed was added in 2022 but will be removed as part of this project.

Mr. Lee Short presented the case for the applicant. The intent of the project is to modify the “cottage” to a full time home. Mr. Simerl has spoke with the neighbors and Mr. Short provided signed document from neighbors in favor of the project. Mr. Short presented the elevation views of the project. The addition is a two (2) car garage addition. The existing shed will be removed. The lot “two front yards” was discussed as both yards abut roadways. The “true” front yard is considered Helmsman Drive with East Port Drive considered the “true” rear yard. Thus, all the addition is in the second front yard (or “true” rear yard). Ms. Dubber noted that most of the adjacent properties are setback at 25 feet (which is the applicants request). There will be both a front driveway (existing) and a rear driveway (new for the proposed garage). Mr. Short indicated that the addition was minimized as best possible to minimize the side yard setback variance including a 21.5 foot wide garage which is narrower than standard garages (24 feet wide).

Chairman Calwell asked if there were any comments from the audience. There were none and the meeting was closed to the floor.

The finding of facts was reviewed with the following results.
Finding Of Facts: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Owner’s Responses: Yes No No No No Yes Yes
Board’s Responses: Yes/Agree 5 0 0 5 5 5 5
No/Disagree 0 5 5 0 0 0 0

The Chair closed the meeting due to no comments from the audience and requested a motion approve, modify or deny the case. Ms. Dubber made a motion to approve the case with the setback variance and was seconded by Mr. Schenk. The case was approved by a 4 Yea, no Nays. The condition for final approval is providing Board with the required elevations and floor plans.

Case 233135: William and Kathleen Nottke 1441 North Orchard Beach Drive
Applicants propose the addition of an attached garage with a bonus room and enclosed patio. The applicants are requesting area variances for the side yard left of 3.17 ft (code is 5 ft), rear yard setback of 16.5 ft (code is 25 ft) and front yard setback of 25 ft (code is 35 ft). The property is located at 1441 North Orchard Beach Drive and is known as Lot 35 of Catawba Orchard Beach Subdivision. The property is zoned R-3.

Additional Information:
A variance was approved to allow for a residence to be built on this lot in 1993 with a 30 foot front yard setback.

Mr. Lee Short was sworn in and represented the applicant for this case. Mr. Short discussed the rear yard drop off that makes the rear yard impossible to work with. The second story will be a bonus room used to house visiting grandchildren. Mr. Short reviewed why the left yard setback is vital for a 1 ½ car garage to house a car and other items such as golf cart and motorcycle trike that would otherwise be stored outside. Mr. Short discussed the lot difficulties with a drop off in the rear yard and utility line also in the back yard. The garage is 17 feet wide with a 14 foot wide door. The garage was minimized to limit the side yard variance. Twenty-four (24) feet would be a standard 2 car garage. A screened porch will be added in the back of the new structure. The bonus room above the garage is connected to the second floor of the existing house. The bonus room also has a second access to the garage. There is also a stairway in the new garage to the bonus room. There is not an exterior entrance to the bonus room. The screened porch has access to the garage but not to the main house. Access from the porch directly to the house was not feasible due to the access would have to go through an existing bedroom. There is an access to the porch via a door from the garage and a door from the porch to rear yard. Mr. Short indicated the adjacent lot (to the left) is a vacant lot.

Mr. Stams was sworn in and discussed that the lot to the left is not empty as he owns 2 lots with his house on one lot. He indicated he is not opposed to the project but wanted to clarify the lot description. Mr. Stams wanted to make sure his property line would not be affected and that any construction will not create a mess on his property. Chairman Caldwell indicated that his property line won’t change as a result of this project. Mr. Short indicated that the excavation is near his property and the contractor should take caution to not create a mess and clean up any disturbance if such occurred on Mr. Stam’s yard.

The side yard setback is 5 feet, not 10 feet, due to the narrow parcel frontage (Section 7 of the Zoning Resolution). There front yard lot width is 50 feet.

Chairman Caldwell asked if there were any comments from the audience. There were none and the meeting was closed to the floor.

The finding of facts was reviewed with the following results.
Finding Of Facts: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Owner’s Responses: Yes No No No Yes No Yes
Board’s Responses: Yes/Agree 5 4 0 0 5 5 5
No/Disagree 0 1 5 5 0 0 0

The Chair closed the meeting and requested a motion approve, modify or deny the case. Ms. Dubber made a motion to approve the case with the setback variances and was seconded by Mr. Schenk. The case was conditionally approved with a vote of Yes by 3 and a single No.

Case 233139: William Riat for the Lukeman Family LLC 4107 E Catawba Road
Applicant proposes a detached garage (accessory building). The applicant is requesting area variances for building height of 18 feet (code is 15 feet) and building size of 836 SF (code is 750 SF, 776 SF noted on the application and agenda was corrected to 836 SF as the stair case was not included in the calculations). The property is located at 4107 NE Catawba Section 3 Lot 8. The property is zoned R4/R5.

Additional Information: The house for this accessory building is under construction under a different Zoning Certificate that did not require a variance.

Mr. Riat was sworn in and explained that the garage area was corrected as the garage is 776 SF without the stairs and 836 SF with the stairs. Stairs are interior to the garage. Mr. Riat explained the project aesthetics and matching to the adjacent house with the home having a cottage look. Mr. Riat had met with the neighbors to the north. A large 12 foot high hedge of arborvitae was added on the north property line as screening. Ms. Hartline indicated that this site also has a permit for a pool that will not need a variance and we are currently working with the applicant on details of the fencing. Mr. Riat indicated that they went 15 feet on side yard, which is above the 10 foot required to soften the impact of the 18-foot height to the adjacent property. He also discussed that the aesthetics of the roof pitch and the need for the 18 foot height. Second floor is for storage. Neither the first floor or second floor have plumbing. The garage second floor will not be rented out.

Chairman Caldwell asked if there were any comments from the audience. There were none and the meeting was closed to the floor.

The finding of facts was reviewed with the following results:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Owner’s Responses: Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes
Board’s Responses: Yes/Agree 5 1 0 0 5 5 5
No/Disagree 0 4 5 5 0 0 0

The Chair requested a motion approve, modify or deny the case. Mr. Heidlebaugh made a motion to approve the case and was seconded by Ms. Dubber. The case was approved with a unanimous vote of five (5) Yes.

Other Business

No other business to conduct.

Approval of Minutes – September 9, 2026

The minutes for the September 9, 2026 meeting were provided to each member and unanimously approved by the Board.

Adjournment

A motion was made to adjourn the meeting, was seconded and passed, and the meeting was adjourned at 7:17 PM.

Respectfully submitted,

__________________                              __________________
Brian Caldwell, Chairman                              Jean Hartline, Secretary

Scroll to Top